Dallas actual property tycoon Crow is the son of an authentic member of The Forbes 400. However he needed to rescue and rebuild the household’s debt laden empire.
Clarence Thomas and Harlan Crow have been mates for 1 / 4 century, sharing a conservative philosophy–and posh holidays, all controversially paid for by Crow. However they could not have come from extra starkly totally different beginnings.
Crow, 73, is the third son of legendary Dallas actual property tycoon Trammell Crow, who earned a spot on Forbes’ very first record (in 1982) of the 400 richest folks in America, tying for twenty sixth with an estimated $500 million web price. (The minimal to make the in the reduction of then was $100 million; You want a minimum of $2.7 billion now.) Harlan got here of age with a repute as a wealthy child who preferred to social gathering–he flunked out of Emory College in Atlanta, earlier than incomes his bachelor’s on the College of Texas. However after becoming a member of his father’s enterprise in 1974, he buckled down and later rescued the household enterprise after the true property market crashed within the late Eighties.
The 74-year-old Thomas was famously born poor—in Pinpoint, Ga., a Gullah-speaking neighborhood close to Savannah based by freedmen after the Civil Struggle. When he was two, his farmworker father deserted his domestic-worker mom and their three youngsters. She later despatched her two sons to dwell in Savannah with their grandfather, who demanded laborious work and laborious finding out. Thomas attended Catholic faculties and even briefly studied for the priesthood, earlier than heading off to the School of the Holy Cross, Yale Legislation Faculty and a collection of appointments by presidents Ronald Regan and George H.W. Bush, culminating in his elevation to the Supreme Court docket in 1991.
The connection between Thomas and Harlan Crow has been a lot within the information recently, after non-profit investigative information website ProPublica dug up particulars of Thomas’ lavish Crow-paid holidays—and extra. In 2014, ProPublica reported final week, Crow purchased the Savannah residence the place Thomas grew up (and his mom nonetheless lives), plus two close by parcels from the justice, his mom and the household of his late brother for $133,363–a transaction that Thomas didn’t disclose as federal legislation seems to require. (Thomas stated in an announcement he didn’t consider he needed to report the journeys, however reportedly plans to amend his 2014 monetary disclosure to incorporate the true property deal. Crow has stated he plans to finally flip the home right into a museum devoted to Thomas.)
A lot of the current protection describes Crow as a billionaire, however he’s by no means appeared on the Forbes Billionaires record. The Crow household is undoubtedly extraordinarily rich. Their Crow Holdings owns, manages or is creating a complete of $29 billion price of actual property. However a lot of that belongs to exterior traders. By our accounting, Harlan Crow and his brothers share a fortune price a minimum of $2.5 billion, although it’s unclear how that cash is break up.
The historically press-shy Crow declined to speak to Forbes. However on Sunday he lastly gave one interview, to The Dallas Morning Information, wherein he took situation with the widespread impression that he’s merely a belief fund child, declaring the tough form the financial system, actual property and the Crow enterprise have been all in when he took over in 1988. “Our firm was additionally in misery,’’ he stated. “Our financial worth had deteriorated. It’s laborious to know if it was zero, but it surely was low.”
The truth is, years of Forbes reporting on the flamboyant Trammell Crow and his boom-bust-boom-bust empire, assist Harlan Crow on that rating. He can rightly declare credit score for rebuilding the household fortune.
B
ack in 1948, Fred Trammell Crow, a CPA by coaching, returned to Dallas from his World Struggle II responsibility as a Naval commander (auditing protection contractors) to run his spouse’s household grain elevator enterprise. After leasing out the corporate’s extra warehouse area, he began constructing–first warehouses, then commerce marts, workplace towers, resorts and multifamily housing. Trammell (he hardly ever used his first title, Fred) took outsized dangers and gained outsized wealth by constructing on spec (with out having a venture totally pre-leased) and holding on to a lot of what he constructed. “The vendor is all the time fallacious,’’ he preferred to say.
Trammell Crow, proven in 1977 at his World Commerce Middle, was at one level the nation’s largest builder and pioneered the creation of big commerce present exhibition areas.
Bettmann/Getty Photos
Crow helped flip Dallas right into a enterprise vacation spot with a bunch of big wholesale show facilities, together with an attire mart and a commerce mart—the place John F. Kennedy was heading in his motorcade to present a speech when he was assassinated in 1963. Crow put his mark on different cities too, creating Atlanta’s Peachtree Middle and San Francisco’s Embarcadero Middle with financier David Rockefeller and architect and builder John Portman. In 1971, Forbes described Trammell as the most important non-public property developer and largest non-public landlord within the nation.
However the true property recession of the early Seventies pummeled the closely leveraged Crow, who narrowly prevented chapter by getting concessions from lenders and liquidating a number of the properties he had lengthy taken delight in holding on to. After that near-death expertise he stopped the dangerous observe of personally guaranteeing financial institution debt, and by 1982 had recovered sufficient to earn that No. 26 spot on the primary Forbes 400 record.
Nonetheless, Crow remained aggressive–and optimistic. So at the same time as Federal Reserve Chairman Paul Volcker’s conflict on inflation drove the U.S. into the second dip of a recession and oil costs started a decade-long slide in 1981, Crow saved on constructing. In 1988, Forbes estimated he was price $775 million (practically $2 billion in at present’s {dollars}). However as Texas actual property cratered, we slashed his estimated web price to $300 million in 1989, his final yr on the record. He died in 2009, on the age of 94, with out ever regaining a spot.
In 1989, as Harlan Crow was starting his lengthy reign as CEO of Crow Holdings, the operation was operating an annual money movement deficit of round $200 million, enterprise companions of the Crows advised Forbes. By then, Texas’ largest banks had failed or been acquired and a few of its workplace buildings have been sitting half empty.
Harlan Crow set about recasting the household enterprise as a supervisor of belongings—in order that even when they needed to default and hand again workplace buildings to lenders, they may nonetheless generate profits protecting them up. He made some laborious nosed strikes in that interval. In 1992, for instance, Forbes detailed how the Crows had dug into their very own pockets to restrict losses for large institutional traders, whereas letting a publicly traded Trammell Crow REIT take the complete hit. A New York Occasions story described how Harlan put relations (together with his mother and father) on a finances and squeezed out companions that the Crows themselves had lent to, demanding they provide up properties.
Harlan Crow unfold the ache past household and companions–to lenders, too. In 1993, the Crow operation defaulted on $170 million in debt on their headquarters, the Trammell Crow Middle in downtown Dallas. In 1994, lenders holding $580 million in debt on the Crows’ prized Dallas Market Middle foreclosed on the property; Harlan went to courtroom and finally bought them to just accept $175 million. (He has since consolidated 68 acres there and is planning a grand redevelopment.)
“I spent about 5 years doing exercises,’’ Crow recalled on Sunday to the Morning Information. “We negotiated with numerous monetary establishments over an extended time period doing all this and we tried to do it as honorably as we may.’’
In 1997 the Crows offered off their Wyndham lodge chain (which Trammell had based in 1981), plus a portfolio of family-owned resorts, for about $600 million money.
After all of the exercises, gross sales and different deleveraging, Harlan went about rebuilding–however extra conservatively than his father. In 1998, he took public the outdated Trammell Crow Co., which was now targeted on the enterprise of managing actual property. Eight years later, CB Richard Ellis acquired the enterprise for $1.9 billion. By then, the Crow household owned lower than 5% of the shares and was as a substitute targeted on build up a separate, privately-held actual property administration enterprise.
Harlan’s brother, Trammell Crow Jr., sports activities a ponytail and types himself as a “inexperienced Republican.” He is proven right here in 2016.
JB Lacroix/WireImage/Getty Photos
Immediately, their Crow Holdings owns and manages practically $30 billion in actual property initiatives each accomplished and beneath building. Harlan Crow and his two youthful brothers Trammell Jr. and Stuart, are listed on Securities and Trade Fee filings as majority homeowners of Crow Holdings Capital. Harlan was CEO of the household operation for practically three a long time. In 2017, he stepped again to the chairman’s function, bringing in an outsider as CEO: Morgan Stanley actual property finance veteran Michael Levy.
Trammell Crow’s youngsters are an attention-grabbing lot. Trammell Jr. has lengthy sported a ponytail and adopted the ethos of a hippie capitalist, or “inexperienced Republican” as he calls it; he even sponsors an annual environmental competition in Dallas referred to as EarthX. Youngest brother Stuart is a retired skilled race automobile driver. (Two older brothers died in 2011 and 2016, respectively.)
Trammell’s solely daughter, Lucy Billingsley, shaped a separate actual property growth and administration firm, Billingsley Firm, together with her husband in 1978. In line with Actual Capital Analytics, Billingsley has stakes in 66 properties price an estimated $2.9 billion (web of debt), together with workplace, warehouse, retail and 10,000 multifamily models, principally in Texas.
The three Crow brothers’ registered funding advisory agency, Crow Holdings Capital, runs $14 billion (of the $29 billion whole managed) via pooled investments—they put up a minimum of $1 billion of the cash, in line with an investor doc, however a lot of it belongs to institutional purchasers, who pay a 1.5% annual price, plus 20% of income. Different belongings are managed via partnerships. It’s unclear from securities filings what share of their managed actual property the Crows personal themselves–they usually’re not speaking.
Harlan Crow appears to have made good cash for his traders. Crow Holdings shaped its first institutional commingled fund in 1998. In line with a doc from one in every of its traders, the Rhode Island division of treasury, Crow’s actual property funds have since averaged charges of return from 10% to 29% every year, excluding a 2006 classic fund that solely made 2% after actual property collapsed within the Nice Recession.
Crow’s $6 billion price of ongoing growth initiatives embrace a 1.2 million sq. foot logistics park in New Jersey; a housing and retail complicated at Alameda Level (former website of a naval air station in the midst of San Francisco Bay); and a 235,000 sq. foot, 7-floor, “mass timber” constructing in Frisco, Texas — constructed completely of wooden. The deal movement continued even throughout the pandemic, throughout which the Crow funds offered a billion {dollars} of business buildings to the likes of Prudential. An Atlanta workplace complicated Crow in-built 2017 in partnership with the California Academics Retirement System, offered in 2021 for $195 million, a 20% annualized return on their four-year funding, CalSTRS has reported. Now, with the Covid-weakened workplace market ailing in lots of huge cities, Crow has raised a $750 million fund for extra industrial growth, plus a $680 million fund to construct residences.
H
arlan Crow’s fortune is clearly sufficiently big to dwell giant and indulge his passions–for amassing, entertaining and backing conservative candidates and causes–on a grand scale. (He’s donated virtually $15 million over the past three a long time to state and federal candidates, events and political committees with the tempo of his giving selecting up lately, in line with OpenSecrets.)
Crow owns a 30,000 sq. foot residence on eight acres within the Highland Park neighborhood of Dallas, appraised by the county at $50 million. In 2015, he constructed a 77-space underground storage in order that he may host occasions on the property, which boasts a yard sculpture backyard that includes useless dictators, together with Stalin, Mao and Castro. Among the many most arresting: an 18-foot-tall, 8-ton statue of Vladimir Lenin, clutching Das Kapital, that was forged in 1970, and knocked off its podium in Lanchkhuti, Georgia after the autumn of the Soviet Union; it took a 30-story excessive crane to decrease it into the backyard. As Harlan Crow advised Forbes in 1996: “That is historical past, and it’s historical past that’s altering earlier than our eyes. Each one in every of these statues has its personal story. Anybody whose mind is working would discover them attention-grabbing.”
Contained in the mansion, together with work by Renoir, Monet and 20,000 books, Harlan retains historic paperwork and memorabilia regarding such notables as Christopher Columbus, Amerigo Vespucci, Robert E. Lee–and Hitler. His Nazi artifacts embrace a signed copy of Mein Kampf, two of Hitler’s work and swastika embossed desk linens. Crow and his admirers say these things (like his backyard of despots) mirror a historical past buff’s want to “never forget” versus a celebration of the Third Reich.
Crow retains extra statues and Americana and holds nonetheless extra occasions on the 12.5-acre grounds of Outdated Parkland, the workplace complicated he reworked out of a boarded up psychological hospital Crow Holdings acquired in 2006. Final yr Crow hosted an American Enterprise Institute occasion there, which featured a dialogue between Clarence Thomas and John Yoo. The $300 million of renovations included the set up of a rotunda modeled on one Thomas Jefferson designed for the College of Virginia. The neo-classical structure has attracted a bunch of hedge funds and household workplaces, stated to incorporate that of Harlan’s good good friend George W. Bush. (Harlan donated greater than $5 million to the George W. Bush Presidential Middle and sits on its board.) The venture may sound over-the-top, but it surely’s been a hit and displays one lesson Harlan clearly realized from Trammell, who advised Forbes again in 1971: “What actual property is, is advertising.” Even a nationwide builder, he stated, wants to know what every native market wants and values in a venture.
Harlan Crow has a few of his dad’s showman aptitude in the case of entertaining, too. There’s his yacht, the 162-foot Michaela Rose, which (once more in line with ProPublica) Crow, Thomas and their wives used for 9 days of island hopping round Indonesia in 2019. (It used to belong to his father and is price $6.5 million in line with VesselsValue.) For that journey, the Thomases flew to Indonesia on Crow’s non-public jet, a Bombardier BD-700, that will go for about $15 million in at present’s used jet market. At his $10 million non-public resort on Lake Saranac within the Adirondack Mountains of upstate New York, Crow hosts Thomas and others each summer time. In line with ProPublica, the non-public resort boasts a portray of the 2 males sitting exterior smoking cigars, alongside three conservative political operatives. Behind them is a statue of a Native American man. Crow’s love of statues and friendship with Thomas is such that he additionally paid for a 7-feet-tall statue of the nun who was Thomas’ beloved eighth grade instructor.
Sculptures are a recurring theme in Harlan Crow’s life. On the Outdated Parkland campus, the place Crow Holdings is developing one other 300,000 sq. ft of workplace area, Crow spent a reported $25 million to construct a 250-foot bell tower and forge a 15-ton bell. To embellish this campanile, Crow has reportedly ordered sculptures made from his personal heroes: Aristotle, free-market economist Milton Friedman and the Roman goddess Fortuna. No phrase but on whether or not he has a statue of Clarence Thomas within the works.
MORE FROM FORBES
